When you receive thousands of dollars in ESA funding each year, it comes with real responsibility. Arizona parents are using these accounts to purchase curriculum, pay for therapies, and cover legitimate educational expenses. But misusing those funds, whether intentional or accidental, can result in serious consequences, from account suspension to criminal prosecution. Understanding the rules and the oversight system helps protect your family from costly mistakes.
The Reality: Fraud Enforcement Is Active and Growing
ESA fraud enforcement is not theoretical. In August 2025, Arizona Attorney General Kris Mayes announced two convictions for ESA program fraud. Johnny and Ashley Bowers, a Colorado couple, pled guilty to fraudulent schemes after submitting forged birth certificates and utility bills to obtain ESA funding for over 40 children- both real and fictitious. They fraudulently received $110,258.28 in ESA funds from December 2022 to May 2024. In a separate case, a Florida man used similar tactics to fraudulently collect up to $25,000.
These aren’t isolated incidents. As of August 2025, approximately 400 ESA accounts out of roughly 90,000 have been suspended for improper spending- about 1% of total accounts. The Arizona Department of Education has recovered or is in the process of recovering $622,000 in misspent funds from 197 individuals. Attorney General Mayes made the state’s position clear: “Fraud in the ESA program will not be tolerated. Those who exploit government systems for personal gain will be held accountable”.
How Arizona Monitors ESA Spending
Arizona uses a multi-layered approach to detect and prevent fraud. The ClassWallet system processes all ESA transactions, creating a digital trail of every purchase. Arizona Revised Statute §15-2403 requires the Department of Education to conduct annual audits, random quarterly reviews, and develop risk-based auditing procedures in consultation with the Office of the Auditor General.
However, the oversight system faces significant capacity challenges. The Department of Education currently has just twelve auditors- the same staffing level it had when the ESA program served one-tenth of its current 100,000+ participants. To address a growing backlog of reimbursement requests, the department implemented an auto-approval system in late 2024 for purchases under $2,000. Since November 2024, approximately $124 million in ESA purchases have been auto-approved with no pre-audit review.
This doesn’t mean those purchases go unchecked forever. Records show the system eventually flags problematic transactions, diamond rings, Victoria’s Secret lingerie, household refrigerators, and requires refunds or corrective action. The problem is delay and volume, not the complete absence of oversight.
Arizona law also establishes an anonymous fraud reporting hotline and online reporting service, allowing anyone to report suspected misuse. The statute explicitly authorizes the State Board of Education to refer cases of substantial misuse to the Attorney General “for the purpose of collection or for the purpose of a criminal investigation if the state board of education obtains evidence of fraudulent use of an account”.
What Counts as Fraud or Misuse
Arizona law distinguishes between honest mistakes and intentional fraud. According to A.R.S. §15-2403, the department may remove a parent from eligibility if they “knowingly misuse money or knowingly fail to comply with the terms of the contract with intent to defraud”. The statute specifically protects parents who are victims of identity theft or fraud themselves.
Misuse includes any spending on non-allowable expenses under A.R.S. §15-2402. Common examples of ineligible expenses flagged by the department include personal jewelry, adult clothing, household appliances not used for educational purposes, and non-educational electronics. Even if you didn’t intend to defraud the program, purchasing ineligible items requires repayment.
Fraud, by contrast, involves intentional deception: submitting forged documents to obtain ESA accounts for fictitious children, claiming Arizona residency while living out-of-state, falsifying receipts or invoices to claim reimbursement, or knowingly purchasing personal items while misrepresenting them as educational expenses.
The Consequences: From Repayment to Criminal Prosecution
If the Department of Education determines you’ve made an ineligible purchase, the first step is notification and an opportunity to correct the issue. Arizona law requires the department to notify you in writing, specify the reason for concern, and give you fifteen days (not including weekends) to respond and take corrective action. If you repay the misspent funds within this timeframe, the money is credited back to your ESA account within 30 days, and in most cases, no further action is taken.
Failure to respond or repeated violations escalate consequences. The department will suspend your account, halting all transactions and disbursements until the issue is resolved. If you continue to refuse contact or fail to furnish required information, the department may terminate your account and remove you from the program entirely. Arizona Administrative Code specifies that if a parent commits fraud, “the Department shall withhold funds from all accounts in the parent’s name”.
For substantial misuse or confirmed fraud, the State Board of Education refers cases to the Attorney General’s Office. At this point, you may face collection proceedings to recover misspent funds, or if fraud is proven, criminal prosecution. The Colorado couple’s case demonstrates the severity: they faced criminal charges for fraudulent schemes, a felony offense in Arizona.
Protecting Yourself: Practical Steps to Stay Compliant
Review the allowable expense database regularly: The Arizona Department of Education maintains an online database of allowable and disallowed expense categories. Before making any significant purchase, verify it qualifies as an eligible educational expense.
Keep detailed documentation: Save all receipts, invoices, and proof of educational purpose for every ESA transaction. If the department questions a purchase, clear documentation protects you. Submit quarterly expense reports on time with complete invoices and credentials.
Understand the appeals process: If the department makes an administrative decision you disagree with, including determinations about allowable expenses or eligibility, you have the right to appeal to the State Board of Education. The department must notify you in writing of this right and the appeals process at the same time they notify you of their decision.
Respond immediately to any department communications: If you receive a suspension notice or inquiry about expenses, you have fifteen days to respond and provide corrective action. Missing this window can result in permanent account termination. Don’t assume silence will make the problem go away; the department has clear statutory authority to refer unresolved cases for collections or criminal investigation.
Moonpreneur is on a mission to disrupt traditional education and future-proof the next generation with holistic learning solutions. Its Innovator Program is building tomorrow’s workforce by training students in AI/ML, Robotics, Coding, IoT, and Apps, enabling entrepreneurship through experiential learning.
